I think I'm similarly dis-invested for having not re-read it for 25 years. I've lost too much fine detail for purism.
Tried to get the kids into the Lion, Witch, and the Wardrobe, but they also bounced off of it, definitely too precious. The tone varied between books though (or so I remember), and I liked the sequels better even back then.
(So adorable I don't know where she comes from. Maybe I'll dig out a picture later. This ain't quite as public as other places.)