Thursday, November 20, 2008 | |
 
 

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

 
Logo by
 

Welcome to our readers' forums, which we fondly call The Arena. You must be REGISTERED to post here.

 
  The Arena  Departments  The Back Page  "It's crap!" I exclaimed...
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
New Post 12/19/2007 9:27 AM
  John McG
284 posts
4th Level Poster




"It's crap!" I exclaimed... 

Not really appropos to the article, but in reading kid's lit to my girls, I note an inverse correlation between the quality of a kid's book and the authors reliance on using the word, "exclaimed," which is a word that seems to only exist in kids' books.

Dr. Seuss can get through great stories without anybody ever exclaiming anything.  So can Sandra Boynton. (They're also writing in verse.)

But those soft-cover books about TV characters on the wire racks in the book store?  Dora's always exlaiming something.  As do, sadly, then Berenstein Bears.  And so on...

 

 
New Post 12/19/2007 11:11 AM
  Keifus
394 posts
3rd Level Poster




said bookisms 
Modified By Keifus  on 12/19/2007 11:14:34 AM)

"Said bookisms" are an editorial word for the abuse of the sort of thing you describe.  The rationale, which you've obviously discovered, is that the word "said" is lucky enough to have dissolved into invisibiliy in depictions of English dialogue, and even that should be used sparingly.  Replied, added, exclaimed, and a hundred other synonyms have an unfortunate habit of drawing attention to themselves, but not communicating very much. 

Classic newbie mistake, I've been told (much to my own chagrin).

 
New Post 12/19/2007 11:20 AM
  Nancy Chase
209 posts
4th Level Poster




Die! Berenstein Bears, Die! 

Weren't one of the Berenstein Bears just arrested last summer?  Yes, it was, for making lewd exclaims to a teenage girl and for starting a fistfight with someone else who was trying to have a picture taken with them.  You just can't trust your oversized animated characters these days.

 
New Post 12/19/2007 11:29 AM
  John McG
284 posts
4th Level Poster




Re: Die! Berenstein Bears, Die! 

My preferred remedy, not eplicitly attributing lines of dialogue, probably isn't available to kid lit authors, so "exclaimed"  will probably live on. 

 
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
  The Arena  Departments  The Back Page  "It's crap!" I exclaimed...
  Maximize
Home | And Now For The News | The Arena | The Comics Page | About Quiblit
Copyright 2008 by quiblit.com | Privacy Statement | Terms Of Use